On the surface, it sounds simple—an Indian student gets accepted into a U.S. university, plans to apply for an F1 student visa, and the parent is already a U.S. citizen. But sometimes, that very same fact—a U.S. citizen parent—can lead to unexpected trouble at the visa counter.
The F1 visa is a non-immigrant status, purely for the purpose of education on the assumption that the student will return to their home country after graduation. Having one parent as a U.S. citizen presents a possible avenue for immigration, and hence the visa officers get suspicious.
Also Read – OPT Warning: ICE Flags EAD Holder as Jobless
Many Indian families who never filed immigration petitions are finding this to become an issue. Even when no green card application was filed, the U.S. embassy can still ask the student about their true intent.
Visa officers are trained to look for signs of “immigrant intent.” A U.S. citizen parent—no matter how inactive on paper—can easily shift the interview tone from academic to suspicious.
Also Read – Driving License Chaos: DMV, USCIS Trap H-1Bs
This has led to some students feeling caught between two systems—neither immigrant nor fully non-immigrant in the eyes of U.S. immigration. And it adds stress to an already anxious process.
Clarity at the interview can help. Many students in this position have been successful in getting visas by explaining calmly that no petition has been filed and the only plan is to study and return after completion of the program.
Also Read – NRI’s Nightmare: Green Card Parents But No H-1B
Honest answers, proof of Indian connections, and good documentation are more likely to prevail than evasiveness. In the end, intent—rather than family status—often decides the outcome.
