Alia Bhatt’s Gangubai Kathiawadi remains one of her most talked-about performances. The role was widely praised for its boldness and emotional depth. Three years after the film’s release, discussions have resurfaced following Alia’s comments on how she was cast.
In a recent interview, Alia said her first planned collaboration with Sanjay Leela Bhansali was Inshallah, which was later shelved. She shared that the cancellation left her deeply disappointed. According to her, Bhansali advised her to take a short break and go on vacation.
Alia further stated that after two weeks, Sanjay Leela Bhansali approached her with the role of Gangubai Kathiawadi. She described the opportunity as unexpected and emotionally significant. Her version suggested the role came as a fresh offer after a pause.
However, Sanjay Leela Bhansali presented a different account in another interview. He said that after Inshallah was shelved, Alia became extremely emotional. He claimed she cried, reacted strongly, and asked others to leave the room.
Bhansali added that around a week later, he offered her Gangubai Kathiawadi. Following the contrasting statements, fans began debating the truth. Many started trolling Alia and questioning her account of how the role came to her.
Some critics allege that Bhansali did not cast her out of initial creative intent. They believe the decision was influenced by her emotional response to losing Inshallah. Several users accused her of misrepresenting events.
There are also claims that her PR team is shaping public perception in her favour. Critics argue that her version will dominate while Bhansali’s statements fade from memory. A few have even labelled her a “role snatcher”.
On the other hand, a section of fans has defended Alia. They argue she never denied being emotional and only chose not to highlight that moment. Supporters believe the backlash is driven by anti-Alia PR narratives.
The contrasting accounts have left audiences divided. With both sides presenting different versions, the truth remains open to interpretation.
