Shubman Gill’s comeback for the Asia Cup 2025 has done more than strengthen India’s squad. It has also sparked fresh debates about the playing XI and the balance of the batting order.
Irfan Pathan Backs Gill as Opener
Former all-rounder Irfan Pathan has made it clear that Gill should walk straight into the opening slot. However, if Gill opens, someone else in the top order may have to step aside.
Vice-Captaincy and Leadership Role
Pathan believes Gill’s return is not only about scoring runs. With Suryakumar Yadav’s backing, Gill’s role as vice-captain is expected to boost India’s long-term plans. Pathan feels his presence will strengthen Surya’s captaincy by adding more leadership depth.
Samson and Jitesh in Trouble?
Pathan hinted at big changes in the Asia Cup playing XI. While Gill is likely to open, Sanju Samson’s position could be at risk. If Samson is pushed to No.5, Jitesh Sharma might lose his place altogether.
The Selection Dilemma
In-form players like Samson and Abhishek Sharma may find themselves sidelined, raising questions about fairness. Instead of solving a problem, Gill’s return could trigger multiple reshuffles in a line-up that had just begun to settle.
Key Question for the BCCI
The main challenge for selectors is balancing talent in a crowded batting line-up. Should Gill’s long-term value outweigh current form and role clarity? This will be the biggest test for India ahead of the Asia Cup 2025.
Spotlight on Gill
The Asia Cup will not only be about India versus their rivals. It will also be about India versus their own selection challenges. All eyes will be on whether Shubman Gill can justify the faith placed in him as a potential opener.
