Shubman Gill’s recent performance in Australia has left Indian fans disappointed and angry on social media. Once hailed as the “Prince of Ahmedabad” and compared to Babar Azam, Gill now faces growing criticism for failing to impress as captain in the 3-match ODI series.
Leadership Under Fire
Despite the big responsibility of leading the team, Gill struggled to make an impact. Fans are questioning whether he can handle pressure in challenging conditions, especially after his lacklustre display with the bat throughout the series.
Poor Show in the Final ODI
In the third ODI, Gill managed just 24 runs off 26 balls, ending the series with the lowest batting average among India’s top six. Even all-rounders like Axar Patel outperformed him, adding fuel to the frustration among fans.
Form and Position Issues
Supporters pointed out that Gill’s poor run isn’t new. Since the Asia Cup, he has struggled to perform consistently, except when opening. His recent shift between batting positions and formats seems to have unsettled his rhythm and confidence.
Conditions Expose Weaknesses
During India’s tour of England earlier this year, Gill batted in the middle order on flat pitches that favoured batsmen. But in Australia, where he opened against fresh bowlers and a swinging new ball, his weaknesses in technique and shot selection were exposed.
Social Media Backlash
Social media is full of comments suggesting Gill performs better in the middle order. Many fans also blame the BCCI for forcing him into captaincy too early and sticking to rigid team plans that restrict his natural game.
Calls for Change
Some fans are demanding that younger players like Yashasvi Jaiswal get more opportunities while Gill rethinks his approach. The criticism has become so intense that a few have even labelled him the “most hated Indian captain” in recent times.
A Defining Moment Ahead
Fans believe Gill still has the talent to bounce back but want him to return to the middle order, where he plays with more freedom. The upcoming matches will be crucial for him to prove his leadership and regain his form before the pressure becomes unbearable.
Prince of Ahmedabad, Indian version of Babar Azam has scored lowest runs from top 6 for team India this series.
Even bowling all rounder Axar Patel has scored more thans than Shubman Gill on these tough pitches!!
For him, World Cup & Champions Trophy winner Rohit got sacked pic.twitter.com/bFNdJ7kcTw
— Rajiv (@Rajiv1841) October 25, 2025
Shubman Gill the new captain of India pic.twitter.com/mB4JTux8z1
— Homie (@homelander_yyy) October 25, 2025
